Anna Maria Vacation Rentals
Our collection of homes in the City of Anna Maria offers a quieter, more residential side of island living, known for its natural beauty, charming streets, and close proximity to Bean Point and the Gulf’s most pristine beaches. This area captures the essence of old Florida, where mornings are slow, sunsets are uninterrupted, and everything feels intentionally unspoiled.
From thoughtfully designed beach homes to private coastal retreats, each stay is curated for comfort, style, and a seamless connection to the island’s most sought-after experiences.
19 properties available
Welcome to Happy Ours!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.JUST RELAUNCHED AS A RENTAL and UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT! Experience Happy Ours — a rare direct beachfront retreat tucked along Magnolia Avenue on Anna
Welcome to Hangin’ on Hammock!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.Tucked along a quiet stretch on the north end of Anna Maria Island, this home blends easy island living with space to gather, unwind, and enjoy the water. Fresh paint, u
Welcome to Casa Mariposa!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.Experience Casa Mariposa where the rhythm of island life slows, and beauty unfolds in every detail. Just one street north of Pine Avenue and four houses from the beach, this elegan
Welcome to La Buena Vida!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.The SpaceMornings begin with sunlight dancing across the canal and coffee enjoyed on the screened porch. Days unfold between the pool, the dock, and the nearby beach—each mom
Welcome to AMI Peppertree Paradise!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.Experience AMI Peppertree Paradise — a light-filled beach home where mornings begin with salt air and end beneath the glow of island skies.Just three houses from th
Welcome to Sea La Vie!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.The SpaceWhere light dances across the water and modern design meets island ease, Sea La Vie invites you to experience the beauty of Anna Maria Island from a space that feels both lux
Welcome to The Cottage on Pine!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.The SpaceStep inside The Cottage on Pine and feel the ease of island life take hold. Gentle natural light, soft coastal hues, and thoughtfully curated details create an atmos
Welcome to Bateman's!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.Experience Bateman’s — where thoughtful design and waterfront living come together.Set along a quiet canal on Anna Maria Island’s north end, this modern coastal h
Welcome to The Curated Palm!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.The SpaceThe Curated Palm is a home that feels at once elevated and effortless — where thoughtful craftsmanship, inspired design, and island living align in perfect h
Welcome to Sea La Vie Beach House!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.The SpaceWhere connection meets calm, Sea La Vie Beach House brings family, friends, and loved ones together in a space designed for comfort, laughter, and easy island liv
Welcome to Coconut Lagoon!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals, a locally owned and operated boutique vacation rental agency.The SpaceStep into Coconut Lagoon, where generations of island charm meet easy, family-focused living. Nestled along the beloved Magnolia Avenue—lined with palms, bike
Welcome to Sunset at 714!On Anna Maria Island (Anna Maria, FL)Managed locally by Once Upon A Beach Vacation Rentals & Property ManagementThe SpaceWhere island sunsets, beach days, and family memories come together.Tucked away on the highly desirable north end of Anna Maria Island, Sunset at 714 places you just a short stroll from the sugar-whit
Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.